Internet Policy Research Website

New Publication | The ambiguity of digital sovereignty between Territorialization of cyberspace and extraterritorial projection of power. Analysing data governance policies in EU, US and China

Publication News

New Open Access Article on the Ambiguity of Digital Sovereignty in the EU, the US and China

Published in Rivista di Digital Politics, the article shows how the EU, the US and China pursue both a territory-bound and an extraterritorial conception of digital sovereignty, with costs for legal certainty and international cooperation.

Rivista di Digital Politics Open Access Focus: Digital Sovereignty 2026
Cover of Rivista di Digital Politics
Rivista di Digital Politics – Il Mulino

The article “The ambiguity of digital sovereignty between Territorialization of cyberspace and extraterritorial projection of power. Analysing data governance policies in EU, US and China”, by Nicola Palladino, has been published in Rivista di Digital Politics, issue 1-2/2026, within the Focus Digital Sovereignty.

Drawing on a qualitative analysis of primary policy documents from the European Union, the United States and China, the article argues that the structural source of current geopolitical tensions lies in the ambiguous way states conceptualise and operationalise digital sovereignty.

Open Access Article

Abstract

Digital sovereignty has emerged as one of the most contested concepts in contemporary international relations, invoked across democratic and authoritarian regimes alike to justify state intervention in the digital environment. This paper argues that the structural source of current geopolitical tensions lies in the fundamentally ambiguous way states conceptualize and operationalize digital sovereignty. Drawing on qualitative analysis of primary policy documents from the European Union, the United States, and China, the paper shows how all three actors simultaneously pursue two conceptions of digital sovereignty: a classical, territory-bound notion grounded in control over infrastructure, data flows, and digital operators within a jurisdiction, and a heterodox, de-territorialized notion that justifies the extraterritorial extension of digital power beyond their borders. Through in-depth analysis of selected data sovereignty policies, the paper documents how this ambiguity generates overlapping sovereignty claims and conflicting regulatory regimes, places private operators in structural non-compliance, and erodes the conditions for multilateral cooperation. The paper concludes that the ambiguity of digital sovereignty is costly for legal certainty, interstate relations, and the individuals whose rights are nominally at its center, and calls for renewed investment in international treaty-making as the most durable path toward a stable transnational legal framework.

Authors

Single-authored research on data governance and digital sovereignty

The article is authored by Nicola Palladino, Assistant Professor at the University of Salerno.

Open Access

The article is freely available under a Creative Commons CC BY-NC-ND licence, as part of the Focus on Digital Sovereignty.

Comments are closed, but trackbacks and pingbacks are open.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Accept Read More